BIG Kids Need Phonics Too Series! Step 1: Diagnostic Assessments
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you make a purchase using these links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Many children can get through kindergarten, first, and second-grade using visual memory, picture clues, and compensation skills. Their reading skills appear fairly intact. Then, around third grade, the text gets more challenging, the words get longer, and the pictures go away. Suddenly, it is obvious that these children are not really competent readers! It is often a time of confusion and frustration for parents and teachers who thought that everything was okay.
The bottom line is that without thorough diagnostic testing, it is difficult to determine if a young child really has the foundational skills needed for reading, mastered or not. This testing should be happening in Kindergarten! In fact, many states have passed laws that require that it is. Early detection of reading and learning disabilities (like dyslexia) is crucial.
Whether it happens in primary grades or not, diagnostic assessments should be given to every person struggling with literacy, regardless of age! Without them, we can’t determine the underlying problem. Time is precious when an intermediate child is struggling to read. We need to identify exactly what skills are missing and then quickly, and purposefully, intervene.
DIAGNOSTIC ASSESSMENTS SHOULD BE GIVEN TO EVERY PERSON STRUGGLING WITH LITERACY REGARDLESS OF AGE!
If you need a Benchmark Assessment to determine if a child is reading at grade level, we love Acadience Reading (formally Dibels Next). These are free grade-level assessments that will give you the indicator that further testing is needed.
Then, use Diagnostic Tests to identify the root cause of the reading problem. These are a few of our favorite, free, easily accessible, and quick diagnostic assessments.
The PAST Test
We know that our series is called BIG Kids Need Phonics Too, but the truth is that we cannot ignore phonological awareness (P.A.) when looking at reading problems. Phonological Awareness is the ability to hear and manipulate the sounds of a language. Phonics is matching those sounds to symbols or letters. Phonics is tied so closely with phonological awareness that we have to look at both to determine the root cause of the reading struggles. You can find out more about P.A. and Phonics in the links above.
Research shows that 80% of children with a significant reading disability (SRD) have a phonological processing deficit. The PAST Test (Phonological Awareness Screening Test) is a comprehensive assessment that is individually administered to determine if a child is proficient in the core components of phonological awareness. The subskills assessed are sentence segmenting, on-set rime, syllables, and phoneme isolation and manipulation. There are two versions of this assessment. One is geared more for primary students and the other offers more advanced phonological awareness and phonemic awaress tasks.
We highly recommend David Kilpatrick’s book Equipped for Reading Success that dives deeply into the importance of phonological awareness. It includes the PAST assessment as well as resources to teach and practice P.A. with students.
PHONICS IS TIED SO CLOSELY WITH PHONOLOGICAL AWARENESS THAT WE HAVE TO LOOK AT BOTH TO DETERMINE THE ROOT CAUSE OF THE READING STRUGGLES.
Check out the advanced PAST test here. This test starts with syllables.
Check out the Primary PAST here. It tests skills at the very beginning like identifying words in a sentence and rhyme recognition. (If your student is not successful with syllables, go back to this!)
CORE Phonics Survey
The next diagnostic assessment is the CORE Phonics Survey. This test determines if a student is proficient in letter names, letter sounds, and decoding at the word level. Each section assesses one phonetic pattern (such as short vowels with digraphs). It concludes with multisyllabic words.
This test is great because it allows you to determine exactly where you need to begin your phonics instruction. It also offers both real and nonsense words. In intermediate grades, it is important to have students decode and spell nonsense words because they have memorized many common real words. For example, if a student reads the top row: tape, key, toe, paid, feet accurately, but struggles reading the bottom row: loe, hine, beap, faim, soat, you have insight that they are not phonetically secure with long vowels. This is where you begin your lessons.
The CORE Phonics Survey includes a place to document progress monitoring as well. After instruction, go back to the assessment to determine if the child is secure in that skill and ready to move on to the next one.
THIS TEST IS GREAT BECAUSE IT ALLOWS YOU TO DETERMINE EXACTLY WHERE YOU NEED TO BEGIN YOUR PHONICS INSTRUCTION.
Check out the CORE Phonics Survey here.
6 Syllable Types- Plus!
One of our favorite diagnostic tests for phonics is 6 Syllable Types- Plus! This test is similar to CORE Phonics as it gives real and nonsense words for each phonetic pattern. Included are real and nonsense words containing the six syllable types (closed, open, silent e, r-controlled, vowel team, consonant -le), plus these additional patterns: soft c and g, -dge/-tch, multisyllabic words, word endings, and phonetically irregular words.
We love that the scoring sheet breaks down the score for real versus nonsense words. It can be obvious at a glance if a child has memorized common words, but not mastered a phonetic pattern. Progress Monitoring can also be recorded.
Again, your students’ results determine where you begin your phonics instruction.
WE LOVE THAT THE SCORING SHEET BREAKS DOWN THE SCORE FOR REAL VERSUS NONSENSE WORDS. IT CAN BE OBVIOUS AT A GLANCE IF. A CHILD HAS MEMORIZED COMMON WORDS, BUT NOT MASTERED A PATTERN.
*We do not find it necessary to administer both the CORE Phonics Survey and 6 Syllables Types Plus! We like CORE Phonics better for primary students because it includes letter and sound recognition. We recommend 6 Syllable Types Plus! for intermediate students because it has more multisyllabic words. Both are great and you can determine which is better for your students.
Check out 6 Syllable Types Plus! here and find the student assessment pages here.
Developmental Word Knowledge Inventory
Both the Core Phonics Survey and 6 Syllable Types Plus! assess a student’s ability to decode or read words. The counter skill that also needs to be tested is a student’s ability to encode or spell.
We find that older kids who have used compensation strategies for years can become fairly proficient readers. However, these kids often have awful spelling! This is one of the greatest indicators that something is wrong. It may be that they have either a phonological processing deficit or that they need phonics instruction!
The Developmental Word Inventory is a basic spelling test. It can be given whole group or one-on-one. This test has 30 words that incorporate all the basic phonetic patterns. It breaks the words into the spelling stages of Early-phonetic, Phonetic, Transitional, and Fluent.
Again, the results of this assessment should drive your literacy instruction. You can find out more about research-based spelling instruction here.
STRUGGLING WITH SPELLING IS AN INDICATOR THAT A STUDENT HAS A PHONOLOGICAL OR PHONETIC DEFICIT.
Check out a basic Word Knowledge Inventory here and a more advanced version here.
Putting it All Together!
Once you have administered these assessments, it is important for you to spend time analyzing the results. What are your student’s strengths? Where are they solid? What gaps do they have? Where are they proficient, but not automatic? Where do they completely fall down?
It takes time, but this is where the magic can happen. You will be amazed at the growth and progress your students can make when you personalize their instruction! Create skill-based reading groups that provide instruction and practice on missing phonetic concepts. Fill a gap and move on to the next concept.
THIS IS THE MISSING PUZZLE PIECE. JUST TELLING OLDER STUDENTS TO “READ MORE” WILL NOT HELP. BIG KIDS NEED, AND DESERVE, TO LEARN THE FOUNDATIONAL SKILLS OF READING.
Want to review all 6 Steps in the BIG Kids Need Phonics Too! Series? Here you go!
Step 1: Diagnostic Assessments
Step 2: Eliminate the Primary Vibe
Step 4: Read High-Interest, Skill-based Passages
Step 5: Kill the Worksheet: Practice Can Be Play